Friday, December 12, 2008

Jewish Parents Lose Again in 15-year Quest to Claim Deduction Granted to Scientology

The 9th Circuit handed defeat today to a Jewish couple which has been trying for 15 years to claim tax deductions for a portion of the tuition they pay to Jewish schools attended by their children.

The fascinating part of Marla and Michael Sklar's crusade is that it is based in part on the Internal Revenue Service's decision to grant Scientologists deductions for 80% of fees they pay for auditing and training.

In a ruling issued more than ten months after the case was argued, the judges curtly dismissed the Sklars' argument that the Jewish schools and the Scientology training are similar. "We... conclude that tuition and fee payments to schools that provide secular and religious education as part of one curriculum are quite different from payments to organizations that provide exclusively religious services," Judge Kim Wardlaw wrote.

That conclusion could have been fleshed out a little more, in my view. The panel also offers no explanation I can see of why the Sklars were denied deductions for fees related solely to after-school classes in Jewish Oral Law, or Mishna. There the analogy to the Scientology "auditing and training" seems particularly strong.

The Justice Department is hailing the ruling here. Jeffrey Zuckerman, a Washington attorney who handled the case pro bono for the Sklars, did not respond to an e-mail asking for his reaction.

In any event, the panel viewed its decision as dictated to a great degree by a 9th Circuit decision in 2002, which addressed some of these issues but seemed to leave doors open for further challenges.

A witty concurring opinion from Judge Silverman in that case famously began this way: "Why is Scientology training different from all other religious training? We should decline the invitation to answer that question."

I attended the oral arguments in this case in February. The panel was openly hostile to the government and seemed inclined, at a minimum, to send the case back down for discovery of the precise details of the Scientology deduction rules. The Sklars were never permitted to see that policy.

Like the earlier panel, the panel which wrote today did seem highly skeptical of the alleged IRS policy toward Scientology, stopping just short of calling the deduction unconstitutional. That policy grew out of the settlement of a vast array of litigation between Scientology and the IRS. The panel which wrote today adopted the earlier panel's conclusion that giving the Sklars (and all taxpayers who pay for religious education) a preference that Scientologists allegedly get would only compound the violation of the Establishment Clause.

What was left up in the air today is who has the power to challenge the IRS's deal with the Scientologists. An ordinary taxpayer once might have had standing to do that, but the Supreme Court did away with that in this kind of case back in 2007. See here. It now looks like the alleged unconstitutionality of the Scientologists' tax deal may be one of those government actions which cannot be remedied in the courts.

22 comments:

blogger sidoarjo said...

This is the perfect blog for anyone who wants to know about this topic. You know so much its almost hard to argue with you (not that I really would want...HaHa). You definitely put a new spin on a subject thats been written about for years. Great stuff, just great!

Stop Korupsi Dan Suap Di Indonesia | Stop Korupsi Dan Suap Di Indonesia | Stop Korupsi Dan Suap Di Indonesia | Stop Korupsi Dan Suap Di Indonesia | CARA BERIKLAN DI INTERNET | Stop Korupsi Dan Suap Di Indonesia

Jittree said...

Good job! THANKS! You guys do a great website, and have some great contents. Keep up the good work.best regard.

online shopping usa

Segala Informasi said...

This is the perfect blog for anyone who wants to know about this topic. You know so much its almost hard to argue with you (not that I really would want...HaHa). You definitely put a new spin on a subject thats been written about for years. Great stuff, just great!

cara beriklan di internet | cara beriklan di internet | cara beriklan di internet | cara beriklan di internet | CARA BERIKLAN DI INTERNET | cara beriklan di internet | CARA BERIKLAN DI INTERNET | cara beriklan di internet | media online | Tips Dan Informasi Terkini

admin said...

As looking out for fairly some time for locating a useful articles or blog posts just about this distinctive concern . Researching in Google I lastly came upon this blog post. Studying this So i am happy to say that I’ve bought an important impression I came throughout whatever I wanted. I most certainly will make sure to remember this weblog and look constantly.

genital warts treatment
acid reflux treatment
blemish treatment
cholesterol lowering foods
constipation remedies
excessive sweating treatment
how to get rid of cellulite
how to stop snoring
head lice treatment
sinus infection home remedy
yeast infection home remedy

admin said...

As looking out for fairly some time for locating a useful articles or blog posts just about this distinctive concern . Researching in Google I lastly came upon this blog post. Studying this So i am happy to say that I’ve bought an important impression I came throughout whatever I wanted. I most certainly will make sure to remember this weblog and look constantly.

anxiety treatment
asthma treatment
depression treatment
diabetes treatment
how to stop smoking
insomnia treatment
lower back pain relief
natural hemorrhoids treatment
natural colon cleanse
how to stop premature ejaculation

admin said...

As looking out for fairly some time for locating a useful articles or blog posts just about this distinctive concern . Researching in Google I lastly came upon this blog post. Studying this So i am happy to say that I’ve bought an important impression I came throughout whatever I wanted. I most certainly will make sure to remember this weblog and look constantly.

rheumatoid arthritis treatment
tendonitis treatment
how to stop premature ejaculation
erectile dysfunction treatment
kidney stones treatment
eczema treatment
natural penis enlargement

Проститутки Питера said...

This is a common practice to use buy Finpecia to treat various type disorders.

Проститутки Питера said...

I cogitate generic Periactin can make it possible to do this.

Проститутки Питера said...

Your post made me remind of buy Propecia, that's very nice!

Проститутки Питера said...

What a nice idea, just like buy valtrex, thanks for the post!

Проститутки Питера said...

I do consider it is possible to do this, thanks very much to buy Zithromax.

James said...

I am happy that I observed this weblog , precisely the right info that I was looking for! .

Joan Steward said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Joan Steward said...

good sotry weight loss pills

Jason Smith said...

Hi,
This is an amazing blog post, Thanks very for the share. Keep posting.

Regards,
Astermeds.com

Nazy Brother said...

Centro Metro This is the perfect blog for anyone who wants to know about this topic. You know so much its almost hard to argue with you (not that I really would want...HaHa). You definitely put a new spin on a subject thats been written about for years. Great stuff, just great!

Firman said...

This is a smart blog. I mean it. You have so much knowledge about this issue, and so much passion. You also know how to make people rally behind it, obviously from the responses. Youve got a design here thats not too flashy, but makes a statement as big as what youre saying. Great job, indeed.

Download Android Apk,
PES Android Apk,
GTA Android Apk,
Assassin's Creed Apk Android,
Talking Tom Cat Pro Apk,
SHADOWGUN Apk Download,
Cut the Rope Apk,
Sonic CD Android Apk
Angry Birds Seasons Apk Android
Where's My Water? Apk Android

Just Friends said...

Without inspiration the best powers of the mind remain dormant. There is a fuel in us which needs to be ignited with sparks. # "24 hour locksmiths "

Cheaters PB said...

KabarHp Great stuff from you, man. Ive read Samsung Galaxy Pocket your stuff before and youre just too awesome. I love Androidblink what youve got here, love what youre saying and the way you say it Men In Black 3 Android. You make it entertaining and you still manage to keep it smart. I cant wait to read more from you. This is really a great blog.

Setya Dwi said...

Nice post .. thanks for share :)
WadahMaya.Com | Cheat PB | RCTI | Lamaran | Animasi | Mutiara | Galau | Puisi ...

Hannah bolton said...

It’s a great site to see. That will help for improvisation of me. Will definitely marked as Bookmark.

cheapest broadband and phone package

percetakan termurah said...

nice one info cetak kalender 2014